Listen/Download Article

I walked through a Big Box retailer this morning. The Big Box retailer in question will remain nameless. It will remain nameless due to the fact that I am about to blast it for underhanded retail tricks worthy of a nineteenth century elixir salesman.

All I needed was a cheap, lightweight arbor, a couple bags of perlite and a few six-packs of pansies. Imagine my surprise to find that environmentally appropriate (read: frost tolerant) annuals and perennials were not the only beauties on display. In fact, I don’t think there could have been more color had I come to this store on a sunny May afternoon.

Now why do I take umbrage with this state of affairs you ask? It’s been a long winter. Why am I not charmed by the appealing impatiens, sweet petunias, and variety upon variety of tomato plants lined neatly in rows? Let me tell you why dear reader. I am a gardener. I know when these plants can safely go in the garden – and last time I checked, I wasn’t living on the Gulf Coast.

To your average Joe & Joanne Innocent walking through this particular store on a simple quest for a packet of Bloomsdale Longstanding, Summer has suddenly come in all her eye-popping majesty. Joe grabs six one-gallon teasers, Joanne snatches four flats of six-pack tempters and, faced with strong, sixinch tomato plants fresh from the hothouse, makes the instant decision to give up on the straggly seedlings currently sitting on her washing machine at home. What they both don’t realize is that three-quarters of the plants they have bought in a horticultural retail frenzy are going to die.

frostAs I write these words, our outside temperature tonight is going to be 29 degrees; tomorrow, probably 27; the night after that, 26. Friends, these are not temperatures in which Impatiens thrive. Nor petunias. Nor in fact tomato plants – no matter how early your girl is. But the smart little marketer in charge of Mid-Atlantic regional sales is not going to tell you this. He is instead going to rely on a retail campaign of Shock and Awe to coax those reluctant dollars out of winter-frozen wallets; and he won’t feel any shame about it either.

I used to be one of the uninitiated. I used to fill my cart with blooming dianthus and flowering peppers and oooh-I’ve-never-seen-that-variety tomatoes, and all things tender and succulent – excited by afternoon temperatures in the low 60’s and not really paying attention in the evening (being fast asleep and twenty at the time).

But that was then.

Now, many years later, having learned my lesson in the frost-blackened leaves of rash purchases, I am angry for those who haven’t, and who will be suckered into buying these plants – and losing these plants – far, far too early in the season.

Sure we’ve seen a lot of warm days. Days that make you break out the shorts and the flip-flops and move mulch by the trailer load onto your vegetable beds (hopefully not while you’re wearing the flip-flops). We’ve sat at baseball practices for our children and leaned our faces back and felt the late afternoon sun on our vampire cheeks. We’ve even had a drink or two out on the deck, and maybe one on the patio with friends – and then we’ve gone inside to a cozy little Prime-Time line-up when the sun goes down.

hailSlowly however, those overnight temperatures are going to climb above the freezing mark (somewhere around the end of April for my 6b garden), and then, more and more of those plants I saw this morning will actually have a decent chance of seeing their first birthdays- especially if you’ve been kind enough to protect them from the weather with everything from row covers to upturned milk jugs.

But until that time, grab a few six packs of pansies, perhaps an ornamental kale or two and focus your attention on preparation, dormant shrub planting & the annual dance of Perennial Musical Chairs. And when you navigate your next retail obstacle course outside the safety zone of a reliable nursery, treat those blooming beauties like an Atkins enthusiast treats a loaf of crusty ciabatta.

Unless of course you have a greenhouse, in which case your peppers started producing last month and nobody, including me, wants to talk to you.

By | 2018-02-20T20:41:33+00:00 March 31st, 2011|

About the Author:

Marianne is the mother of two, wife of one and the voice of The Small Town Gardener. She gardens and writes from her home in the scenic (and exceptionally convenient) heart of Virginia's wine country.


  1. John March 31, 2011 at 9:50 pm - Reply

    I think that your writeup explains why I saw them putting those plants on the inside of said big box store instead of outside the store where they used to kill them off without the help of consumers…

    By the way, if you tell yourself that you are a 7A instead of a 6B it gives you a license to buy many more plants 🙂

    • MB Willburn April 4, 2011 at 3:49 pm - Reply

      When I saw them two weeks ago, they had all of the toms and peppers etc… outside on those large racks that look permanent but are movable – you can bet they were going inside that night! I have no problem with starting things early and protecting them, but many people aren’t thinking this way. Hope your seedlings are out in cold frames now!- Marianne

  2. Nicole September 19, 2012 at 6:56 pm - Reply

    Greetings from a zone 2 in B.C. Canada

    Hello Marianne!

    Given my zone I concur with ‘greenhouse envy’ although I still find myself experimenting with tomatoes that just aren’t meant to be here (grin). I started Roma seeds indoors April 15 and transplanted them on July 1st outdoors. It’s Sept 18th as I write this and ONLY NOW are half my blooms fruiting and all of them still green. If it weren’t for two layers of poly our -2 nights would have finished them off but that’s life in the great white North.

    I’d like to weigh in on the discussion about big box stores putting out adorable little seedlings in the wrong season by pointing out that they are notorious for having seasonal dyslexia. I mean what’s up with putting bathing suits in the stores in like January but do you think I can find a single bikini come June?

    Just saying…that’s my pet peeve (hh)


    • MB Willburn September 20, 2012 at 8:17 am - Reply

      Wow – nothing like reading about Zone 2 tomato woes to make me stop sniffling over tropicals I am having to bring in now due to early cool temps. Thanks for the perspective Nikki!

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.